Why did Jane Kim create the “Ninth Street Power Retail SUD” …

… and what the heck is a power retail special use district anyway?

Update: the Planning Commission chose not to support this legislation, voting it down 4-2, with only Commissioners Antonini and Wu in favor. 

Supervisor Jane Kim has introduced legislation that would exempt 555 Ninth Street, that hulking complex at the corner of 9th and Bryant Street, from current zoning controls on formula retail uses (chain stores). The legislation will be reviewed by the Planning Commission on Thursday. 

When the Eastern Neighborhoods Plan was adopted in 2009, the area was rezoned as an Urban Mixed Use (UMU) district, which requires Conditional Use (CU) authorization for formula retail establishments.

The Planning Department case report notes that “formula retail controls were primarily adopted to protect the aesthetic character of the city’s Neighborhood Commercial Districts (NCDs) and South of Market Mixed Use Districts (MUDs).” They imply that this neighborhood doesn’t have any character worth protecting. In truth, Planning Code Sec. 703.3 finds that formula retail controls were enacted because:

“The unregulated and unmonitored establishment of additional formula retail uses may unduly limit or eliminate business establishment opportunities for smaller or medium-sized businesses, many of which tend to be non-traditional or unique, and unduly skew the mix of businesses towards national retailers in lieu of local or regional retailers, thereby decreasing the diversity of merchandise available to residents and visitors and the diversity of purveyors of merchandise.”

UMU also requires that retail uses be limited to a maximum floor area of 25,000 gross square feet. That same standard is included in the proposed Service, Arts and Light Industrial (SALI) district to the north of the property. Above 25,000 gross square feet, three gross square feet of other permitted uses are required for every one gross square foot of retail space, a provision intended to protect the service and light industrial nature of the area. Section 121.6 of the Planning Code also requires a CU for anything over 50,000 sq. ft, and prohibits any single use larger than 120,000 sq. ft.

Kim’s legislation would:

  • change the status of formula retail in the proposed SUD to be a principally permitted use;
  • remove the maximum parking limits in the new SUD;
  • exempt the SUD from the “Showplace Square Special Sign District;” and
  • exempt the SUD from the use size limits that apply elsewhere in UMU.

Supervisor Eric Mar is currently working on legislation that would include financial institutions in the definition of Formula Retail. In this case, since it would become an as-of-right use, there would be no limits on such a use. Chase Bank has long been rumored to be interested in this location. The complex currently includes Bed Bath and Beyond, Trader Joes and the Nordstrom Rack

While the Planning Department is favorably disposed to recommend passage of the legislation, they would like to remove the exemption for sign controls, retain the maximum parking controls and most importantly require a CU for any single use that is above 90,000 sq. ft. Bed Bath and Beyond, currently the largest tenant in the complex, comes in at just under 75,000 sq. ft.

Jane Kim’s office argues that the Ninth Street Power Retail Special Use District would allow the continued use and operation of the 555 Ninth Street retail center for large formula retail tenants. “They’re already there. We don’t see why new tenants should have to go through the CU process,” April Veneracion noted.

The Planning Department adds that the SUD will help attract new businesses to vacant retail space by reducing process and startup costs, as well as allow existing businesses to expand in the proposed SUD with less process and cost. Furthermore, they argue, these businesses tend to provide jobs for semi-skilled workers.

Jim Meko, chair
SoMa Leadership Council 


Leave a comment

Filed under planning, politics

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s